Many managers — especially in agencies — end up getting those roles because they were very good at what they do.
That doesn’t make them good managers.
On the flip side, good managers sometimes struggle to manage good doers.
I’ll explore this later in this week’s newsletter, but first, let’s look at what Jen has rounded up for us this week.
— Chip Griffin, SAGA Founder
Jen’s Weekly Roundup
Here’s what caught my eye this week:
AI CAN DO THE WORK, NOT THE THINKING — David C. Baker at Punctuation walks through fifty years of eroding agency advantages and argues AI is the biggest earthquake yet, one that will shrink firms, flatten hourly billing, and leave expertise as the last moat standing. At Spin Sucks, Gini Dietrich shows what it looks like when a brand skips the “why.” Jaguar’s new $130,500 car now gets a mostly cautious “not yet” from the AI assistants she asked, because the company never bothered to publish the story behind its two-year disappearance. Blair Enns at Win Without Pitching discloses when his own writing and cover art are AI generated, and says that because of AI, creativity is becoming even more valuable.
RENT THE PLATFORM, OWN THE LIST — Gayle Falkenthal tells Karen and Michelle at That Solo Life how an AI moderation bot shut down her Facebook account in the middle of the Paul vs. Tyson fight, and it took a 16-month battle and a small claims filing to get it back. Any client whose community lives on someone else’s platform is one automated flag away from a crisis. Her email list and newsletter are the only channels that have never disappeared on her.
BE DIFFERENT BEFORE YOU FIX PRICING — Robin Bonn tells Marcel Petitpas on the Agency Profit Podcast that the market isn’t oversupplied, it’s underdifferentiated, and no pricing model rescues an agency that hasn’t figured out what makes it stand out. Travis Robertson of Colossus tells Sharon Toerek on The Innovative Agency that the difference still lives in the work, since execution is commoditized, but real creativity and candor with clients aren’t.
GHOSTED PROSPECTS AREN’T GONE, THEY’RE JUST SLOW — Lee McKnight Jr at RSW/US digs into their new agency business development report and finds that pushing harder after a prospect goes quiet backfires, since buyers spend most of their decision time on internal conversations agencies never see. A slower follow-up plan beats another “just checking in” email.
PROTECT YOUR CALENDAR BEFORE DECEMBER TAKES IT — Farin Lesch at HR Transformed cites a Modern Health finding that 57% of employees call the holidays the most draining stretch of the year. Her fix is to block your best hours now before year-end check-ins and parties fill the gaps. Agency teams juggling client year-end crunches need that protection more than most.
STOP BEING THE BOTTLENECK, START BUILDING THE BENCH — George Rivera tells Steve Guberman on Agency Bytes that most agency owners don’t realize they’re the bottleneck until a “freedom audit” shows how much of the week still runs through them, and that delegating outcomes instead of tasks is the only way out of what he calls founder prison. And Brad Farris at Anchor Advisors argues that a team you can actually count on to keep its word, or flag it fast when it can’t, is worth more than any poster on the wall that just says “integrity.”
— Jen Griffin, SAGA Community Manager
Managers and Doers
Often when you are good at your job, you end up getting promoted. Eventually that promotion comes with direct reports, so now you’re a manager.
It’s a path that’s followed because you want to keep your strong performers, and one way to do that is through promotions — but most agencies can’t afford high-paid performers who don’t also take on at least some management responsibilities.
On the other hand, someone might be a really good manager but find themselves struggling to manage top performers, especially if they don’t possess similar knowledge and expertise.
The tension between managers and doers represents a real challenge for many businesses.
So as an agency owner, what do you do about this? (There’s a good chance you see yourself reflected in the above, too.)
You need to start by thinking carefully about who you move into managerial roles as well as who they will be managing.
A perfect example is when you have more technical team members. A great manager without any technical knowledge may struggle to manage them effectively because they won’t understand the workflows or be able to spot problems early.
Similarly, someone with no management experience may struggle to manage a team, particularly if they see themselves as better at performing the actual tasks. Often that leads to micromanagement or a failure to delegate.
In both cases, you need to make sure these managers get adequate training, mentorship, and other support.
If they lack management experience, find internal or external resources to help them develop the skills they need.
If they lack technical knowledge, encourage them to ask questions more often than they issue directives as they build their understanding.
When you have these potential mismatches, you also need to be acutely aware of where the weaknesses in the structure lie so that you can lend a hand, offer guidance, and spot issues early.
Managers play a vital role in delivering results for clients and retaining the best talent for your agency.
It’s worth investing your time and the firm’s resources in cultivating those managers and setting them up for success.